| | Stephen Tewksbury, Jonathan Christopher, Alicia Kaori, Kristie Dale Sanders, Daniel Torres, Josh Groban & Stephen Sondheim | The Letter | |
| | Rebecca Luker, Kristie Dale Sanders, Mary Kate Law, Martha Hawley, Sylvia Rhyne, Margaret Shafer, Siri Howard, Jeanne Lehman, Jeanine Tesori & Steven Tyler | Simple Things | |
| | Rebecca Luker, Patti Cohenour, Laura Benanti, Jeanne Lehman, Lynn Pinto, Julie Prosser, Mary Kate Law, Margaret Shafer, Kristie Dale Sanders, Sylvia Rhyne, Nora Blackall, Siri Howard, Michelle Rios, Betsi Morrison, Martha Hawley, Morgan Billings, Andrea Bowen, Rachel Beth Levenson, Ashley Rose Orr, Marshall Pailet, Lou Taylor Pucci, Tracy Alison Walsh & David Nehls | This Little Light of Mine / Go Tell It on the Mountain | |
| | Rebecca Luker, Patti Cohenour, Laura Benanti, Lynn Pinto, Julie Prosser, Jeanne Lehman, Mary Kate Law, Margaret Shafer, Michelle Rios, Kristie Dale Sanders, Sylvia Rhyne, Nora Blackall, Siri Howard, Betsi Morrison, Martha Hawley & David Nehls | A Merry Christmas Feeling - It's a Wonderful Life | |
| | The Broadway Cast Of "Urinetown" | Christmastime on Highway 13 (feat. Kristie Dale Sanders) | |
| | Kristie Dale Sanders, Siri Howard, Jeanne Lehman, Sylvia Rhyne, Mary Kate Law, Margaret Shafer & David Nehls | I Wonder as I Wander | |
| | Laura Benanti, Nora Blackall, Patti Cohenour, Martha Hawley, Mary Kate Law, Jeanne Lehman, Rebecca Luker, Betsi Morrison, Lynn Pinto, Julie Prosser, Sylvia Rhyne, Michelle Rios, Kristie Dale Sanders, Margaret Shafer & Steven Tyler | Silent Night | |
| | Lynn Pinto, Patti Cohenour, Sylvia Rhyne, Martha Hawley, Mary Kate Law, Kristie Dale Sanders, Siri Howard, Jeanne Lehman, Margaret Shafer & Gannon Mc Hale | Good King Wenceslas | |
| | Kristie Dale Sanders, Laura Benanti, Julie Prosser, Lynn Pinto & Betsi Morrison | God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen | |
