| | The Barbara Carroll Trio, Isabel Bigley & Bill Hayes | A Very Special Day, That's the Way It Happens | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Stubby Kaye, Johnny Silver, Douglas Deane, Guys and Dolls Original Broadway Cast Chorus, Irving Actman & Frank Loesser | Runyonland Music - Fugue for Tinhorns - Follow the Fold (From "Guys and Dolls") | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Vivian Blaine, Guys and Dolls Original Broadway Cast Chorus, Irving Actman & Frank Loesser | Marry the Man Today (From "Guys and Dolls") | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Robert Alda | I'll Know | |
| | Vivian Blaine & Isabel Bigley | Marry the Man Today | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were a Bell | |
| | Robert Aldo & Isabel Bigley | I've Never Been In Love Before | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | You Are Never Away | |
| | Robert Aldo & Isabel Bigley | I'll Know | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | If I Loved You | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Robert Alda, Irving Actman & Frank Loesser | I've Never Been in Love Before (From "Guys and Dolls") | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | Oh, What a Beautiful Mornin' | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were a Bell | |
| | Joan McCracken & Isabel Bigley | It's Me | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were a Bell | |
| | Robert Alda & Isabel Bigley | I've Never Been In Love Before | |
| | The Barbara Carroll Trio, Isabel Bigley & Bill Hayes | A Very Special Day, That's the Way It Happens (From "Me and Juliet") | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | Finale | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Irving Actman & Frank Loesser | If I Were a Bell (From "Guys and Dolls") | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were a Bell | |
| | Stubby Kaye, Johnny Silver, Douglas Deane, Isabel Bigley & Mission Group | Runyonland Music / Fugue for Tinhorns / Follow the Fold | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | Out of My Dreams | |
| | Robert Alda & Isabel Bigley | I've Never Been in Love Before | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Bill Hayes & The Barbara Carroll Trio | A Very Special Day / That's the Way it Happens | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Bill Hayes, The Barbara Carroll Trio, Mark Dawson, Joan McCracken & Bob Fortier | Finale | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Bill Hayes & Salvatore Dell' Isola Orchestra | I'm Your Girl | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Robert Alda | I've Never Been in Love Before | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were A Bell | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | It's a Grand Night for Singing | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Robert Alda, Irving Actman & Frank Loesser | I'll Know (From "Guys and Dolls") | |
| | Joan McCracken, Isabel Bigley & Salvatore Dell' Isola Orchestra | It's Me (From "Me and Juliet") | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Bill Hayes | No Other Love | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | No Other Love Have I | |
| | Robert Alda & Isabel Bigley | I'll Know | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | People Will Say We're in Love | |
| | Stubby Kaye, Johnny Silver, Douglas Deane, Isabel Bigley, Vivian Blaine, Sam Levene, Robert Alda, Pat Rooney Sr., the Guys And Dolls Orchestra & Irving Actman | Reprise: Guys and Dolls | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Bill Hayes | I'm Your Girl | |
| | Isabel Bigley, The Barbara Carroll Trio & Bill Hayes | That's the Way It Happens | |
| | Robert Alda & Isabel Bigley | I'll Know | |
| | Stubby Kaye, Johnny Silver, Douglas Deane & Isabel Bigley | Runyonland Music – Fugue for Tin Horns – Follow the Fold | |
| | Vivian Blaine & Isabel Bigley | Marry the Man Today | |
| | Vivian Blaine & Isabel Bigley | Marry the Man Today | |
| | Isabel Bigley & Stephen Douglass | Overture | |
| | Robert Alda & Isabel Bigley | I’ve Never Been In Love Before | |
| | Salvatore dell'Isola Orchestra, Isabel Bigley, Bill Hayes, The Barbara Carroll Trio, Mark Dawson, Joan McCracken & Bob Fortier | Intermission Talk | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were A Bell | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were a Bell | |
| | Isabel Bigley, Bill Hayes & Salvatore Dell' Isola Orchestra | No Other Love (From "Me and Juliet") | |
| | Stubby Kaye, Johnny Silver, Douglas Deane & Isabel Bigley | Overture / Runyonland Music – Fugue for Tin Horns – Follow the Fold (From "Guys & Dolls") | |
| | Isabel Bigley | If I Were A Bell | |
