| | Vivian Blaine & Sam Levene | Sue Me | |
| | Sam Levene, Stubby Kaye & Johnny Silver | The Oldest Established | |
| | George Gobel, Harold Gary, Larry Alpert, Albert Linville & Sam Levene | If Flutterby Wins | |
| | George Gobel | He Needs You (feat. Larry Alpert?Albert Linville & Sam Levene) | |
| | Stubby Kaye, Johnny Silver, Douglas Deane, Isabel Bigley, Vivian Blaine, Sam Levene, Robert Alda, Pat Rooney Sr., the Guys And Dolls Orchestra & Irving Actman | Reprise: Guys and Dolls | |
| | George Gobel | I'll Learn Ya (feat. Sam Levene) | |
| | Sam Levene, Stubby Kaye & Johnny Silver | The Oldest Establishment | |
| | Vivian Blaine & Sam Levene | Sue Me | |
| | Vivian Blaine, Sam Levene, Irving Actman & Frank Loesser | Sue Me (From "Guys and Dolls") | |
| | Sam Levene | Let it Ride | |
| | Sam Levene, Stubby Kaye & Johnny Silver | The Oldest Established | |
| | George Gobel, Harold Gary, Larry Alpert, Albert Linville & Sam Levene | He Needs You | |
| | Vivian Blaine & Sam Levene | Sue Me | |
| | George Gobel & Sam Levene | I'll Learn Ya | |
| | Sam Levene, Stubby Kaye, Johnny Silver, Guys and Dolls Original Broadway Cast Chorus, Irving Actman & Frank Loesser | The Oldest Established (From "Guys and Dolls") | |
| | George Gobel | If Flutterby Wins; Finale (feat. Sam Levene, Larry Alpert, Albert Linville & Harold Gary) | |
| | Vivian Blaine & Sam Levene | Sue Me | |
| | Sam Levene | Let It Ride | |
| | Vivian Blaine & Sam Levene | Sue Me | |
| | Sam Levene, Stubby Kaye & Johnny Silver | The Oldest Establishment | |
